?? Work at Pickup Points � Flexible schedule

Real Amp vs Emulation Amp, which is better? #musicproduction #guitar

AudioHaze 271 views

Download Video

Comments

real amp
Comment from : @mattsawmiller3277

Why not both? I have a di box split my signal into two I have one signal going to a real tube amp on stage for that great pushed air feeling The other signal goes to a modeler to the front of house PA system I can have awesome stage sound with a great modeler impulse response captured by a sound engineer Everyone always argues, but I see very few using both besides Rabea Massaad I forgot to mention that you’re not stuck with a particular tone when using plugins You can constantly tweak it after recording it Sure, you can re-amp something with a tube amp, but it’s significantly more tedious
Comment from : @Comoguitargeek

So That is why Metallica's new performances sound like Shit got it
Comment from : @ddroz23

Amp sim sounds thinner
Comment from : @OvidiuBolocan

Real amp all the way up sounds great
Comment from : @HugoMejia-i3b

Real amp
Comment from : @lavagander6986

Which amp simulator is that?
Comment from : @DM-lv7tl

What amp sim is he using?
Comment from : @ignacio1818

I’m a pianist/ keyboardist primarily, but when I do put down guitar tracks the Line6 FX 100 fits into the mix perfectly Not saying that it would work as well for live situations (since I only do studio), but it fills the bill nicely for my applications
Comment from : @kurtfroberg3608

Real amp sounded airy and had a punchier ambience to it for cleans
Comment from : @wajikhantv

I think the amp sounds still clears pretty significantly on this one
Comment from : @marcolucchin9391

AMP always
Comment from : @facunditobarra777

Sims are a great tool, but they aren't perfect They always seem to be missing some high-end information in them But in a mix, I doubt most people could tell Certainly not non-musicians
Comment from : @masterofreality230

I just enjoy having a physical amp It’s not always about tone for me
Comment from : @rkturn7393

We are close And even acceptable But clean tones are lacking a bit off life The biggest short coming being spring verb emulations A few more years and we will superior in all ways
Comment from : @TyrannyInOil

Hard to tell the difference to be honest 👍😎
Comment from : @andrewharris6347

My Deluxe Reverb doesn’t require firmware updates
Comment from : @vox1962

1
Comment from : @paulmckenna9492

amp
Comment from : @exactasa

its a good question, im 50 so im old school, I prefer real gears
Comment from : @bobayersquebec

My personal viewpoint is I cant tell a difference on youtube, also a huge stadium band using fractal or something similar i probably couldn’t tell either… but for me personally performing in a small venue, I LOVE using a valve amp I even love seeing a good old Marshall Stack… I also don’t have a problem with guitarists who prefer amp modelling brbrMost of the people who get upset with me using a half stack Marshall or combo are always guitarists though which I believe is silly brbrLive & let live i say !
Comment from : @keviniverson

Sim was thin sounding Not enough lower mids
Comment from : @chevalij

Real amp sounded real fake amo sounded fake
Comment from : @doormasterjohn

Thinking about the difference between looking at a real aquarium vs watching a high def digital video of an aquarium on a flat screen tv… both are fine, but with the real aquarium the side view and top view are way more interesting than those viewing angles of the flat screen tv brGuess I’m the only Boomer watching this video and reading the comments…
Comment from : @vincerusso5619

Neither
Comment from : @haysfordays

How much delay / latency is there on the sim, in a live show for example?
Comment from : @Angzarrr

Emulation was notably thinner Real amp had more dimension to it
Comment from : @Joshurami

none of my emulators taker other pedals the same way that a real amp does as soon as you add a fuzz pedal it gets weird
Comment from : @japmn1

The VST sounded warmer, less "brilliant" (as in, less treble), but the real one had a bit more high end, which resulted in higher definition Both are good tones though For me, it depends on the character of the tone I am after, and the application Its much easier to record a tone using VSTs, even if you were using a re-amp box with a real amp, and VSTs still sound convincing That said, for smaller live gig, I'll gladly use a real amp instead, unless I want the digital character of a modeler (which is valid)
Comment from : @hippyhobo6285

Real amp still to me sounds more natural but I'm not against amp sims, I'm just more used to real amps since that's what I've always used
Comment from : @originalmusicandfilmakers5657

Emulation
Comment from : @javierguajardo1760

The higher notes sounded better on the amp demo to me
Comment from : @fredrodnick2881

Might sound as good but doesn't feel as good to play through
Comment from : @mgrgin

A sim can sound as close as you want but will never feel the same under your fingers verses cranked up tubes
Comment from : @gibs8412

amp pero es muuuuuy muuuy similar y creo 1000 veces mas practico para llevar a algun lugar lo digital
Comment from : @GUITARRACHIRI

But do you feeeeeel the difference😂
Comment from : @calebriley7466

I like touching knobs and filling up a room with fun stuff But there is no meaningful difference
Comment from : @78thandSynth

I like the amp better but 999 of people won’t be able to tell the difference
Comment from : @User74757-c

There’s little point trying to do a tone comparison of such nuance through YouTube audio The only time a guitarist should try to make this kind of decision is playing the two for themselves side by side in the same room
Comment from : @davidburke2132

Maybe if you did that blind style it would be more unbiasedbrBut i imagine depth and more tactile response from the real amp
Comment from : @808stevan

The real one It sounds real
Comment from : @declancurthoys9460

Number 1
Comment from : @johnpick8336

That amp sim maybe it’s quieter but it didn’t sound as good personally Idk I use amp sims but the feels off a real amp nothing beats the speakers and I know even running a digital pedal into an analog preamp just gives it a feel
Comment from : @micktheman6

I like the one with toan!
Comment from : @BeforeAndAfterScience

1
Comment from : @che2335

R e al amp
Comment from : @jeffley2523

Amp sims are sick now for sure But the amp sounded way better in this instance
Comment from : @vdchile27

Sims are NOT THERE YET They just aren’t
Comment from : @wintersmill4853

Amp
Comment from : @strangemalcolm1509

dont care If you have it, use it Play well, it will sound good
Comment from : @irawangani1

I think it doesn't matter because the magic is in the player's hands
Comment from : @Squirrel-i6u

First
Comment from : @sabpaj2824

A lot of programs have mic placement options as well I have not used a mic on a cab since discovering amp sims they just work
Comment from : @themixmasterdylanshow247

Not equal if you want feedback also volume has a large effect on many things sims are fine but still very lacking in what makes things exciting As someone who has recorded for decades using all the stuff it isn't there yet
Comment from : @morbidmanmusic

BS guitar playing
Comment from : @JohnAkweiECMpERMp

The important difference between the two approaches can be heard on rhythm guitar parts The moving air coming from a real speaker hits the mic in such a way that the chug or the boom sounds like it hits you in the chest And currently at this point , amp simulators can’t simulate this for some reason Therefore, at least with regards for rhythm recordings ,I think amp is best, but for lead guitar, both of them are close enough
Comment from : @TheCrimsonCurtains

Don’t like front of house Someone besides you is controlling your entire output
Comment from : @edwinwise6751

Amps make noisebrNo one uses real amps in big showsbrKemper modelers are nearly ubiquitous in stadium rock, metal and country
Comment from : @TheSamknu

Both sound great!
Comment from : @kvp4862

Real sound fuller
Comment from : @varanidfury8634

Most amp emulators already provide the ability to "move the mic"
Comment from : @SamBrockmann

10000 real amp🎉
Comment from : @libturdfanai

The presence and dimension of the mic’d amp is unquestionable in comparison with the emulated amp, which sounds two dimensional, flat and even cheap in comparison - at least in this test !
Comment from : @PandaThiefChannel

i feel like there’s some imperfections in the presence of the amp which kind of adds some realness (for me anyways) but the sim is definitely clearerbrsituational uses ig 🤷‍♀️
Comment from : @jessinsurfgreen4964

I use modeling exclusively, but the real amp sounds better here It has a tight growling depth in its lows and a crisp glassiness in its highs that the sim lacks
Comment from : @400_billion_suns

The amp sounds better
Comment from : @tthreepo4291

If you're recording it's indistinguishable if you have the right gear For playing live you still need amplification, so have to run your modeler into a FRFR, or FOH, or IEM's An amp you just plug in and start wailing 😀
Comment from : @rigorhead01

Amps sound better in person, but the reality is, modern IR will always sound better for large-scale entertainment, unless the artist is playing live from in studio 😂
Comment from : @jakenuno9900

Not a fair comparison Should have turned the drive up or boosted the decibels on the emulated example
Comment from : @Ty-138

Sim is missing the high end shimmer
Comment from : @astronorthwet636

Nah I’ll still take a huge three stack of Marshall super 100s👌
Comment from : @sebby533

I think I liked the plugin
Comment from : @lilbigmanrecords1708

The second one might be smotther, but it's the settings
Comment from : @davidcole5183

I will say in most of the venues we play, it is so much harder to get an amp sim to sit in the mix well We use a fender hot rod which pretty much always sits nicely in the mix You really need to know how to EQ though to get the most out of the Strymon iridium which we also use live sometimes
Comment from : @oisinfitzgerald5401

I wouldn't be able to say which is which, if you don't tell me But the first one had bit more fine distortion and had more dinamic range I could hear soft and loud as you played But both sounds good
Comment from : @dowalt

The amp Not too good of explainig why, but the amp had a better tone to me
Comment from : @Einungbrekke

Amp
Comment from : @luckysevensAltRock8

104 of people that prefer the real one shouldn't recognize the difference in a true blind test
Comment from : @AlessandroRorato

First one Real amp No contestbrbrMore air, mike placement will change it a hundred ways A sim, all your hear is a Fender Stratocaster; a real amp, you hear Fender guitar and a Fender ampbrbrAnd, I'm sorry, but it's not fair to note Metallica or Phish - they aren't bands concerned with "guitar tone" I have nothing g but respect for Tim Henson; but what he's doing isn't relevant to "guitar tone" bands - that's not what he's looking forin fact, most up and coming guitarists probably aren't inspired by guitarists who's whole career was devoted to guitar tone, analog or otherwise Plus, they're most likely not even going to load an amp or carry one around Not harshing, it's just a fact It's a different world - they are concerned other stuff than "how to maximize" the sound of a electric guitar
Comment from : @zombiewooof

You should do a blind test I dont know if i am being biased, but the amp sounds much better to me
Comment from : @js78910

Amp
Comment from : @ficknoti

2, the sim, would turn me off from wanting to play my guitar, and 1 gets me excited for it and everything coming next from that amp
Comment from : @JaiceyLynnWins