?? Work at Pickup Points � Flexible schedule

Mana yang Lebih Baik? Memainkan Musik dengan Telinga vs. Membaca Musik

Learn Piano with Jazer Lee 40 views

Download Video

Comments

🕘 Timestamps br0:00 Intro br0:50 Why Play By Ear? br1:31 PBE Pros br2:52 PBE Cons br6:04 Why Read Sheet Music? br7:15 RSM Pros br8:05 RSM Cons
Comment from : @jazerleepiano

I have a problem, I have musical ear, I played the whole time by it But right now when I want to learn from notes I can't It's really hard! My concentration is bad bcs of the musical ear that will will find the note faster before I even find that note in the paper!
Comment from : @WillWilliamspianoo

Im not a pianist but a mandolinist I play with sheetmusic Only lately I have begun to play by ear and I agree both worlds complement very well
Comment from : @SweetMandolinbyLG

Thanks for your teaching For me I would prefer learning both, can you please be a help
Comment from : @augustinetnyumah1554

I wish I could do it?
Comment from : @baohwadeng

I prefer to play by ear but learnt reading chords
Comment from : @baphiwe87

There is absolutely no doubt at all for me in my 80s that first learning to play piano when I was 10 by only learning to read and play put me at a disadvantage compared to those who discovered how to play by ear Only in old age have I really discovered what “making music” means - and can really appreciate listening to music too, through now learning to use my ears and in-built memory rather than only being able to read and play Everyone should do both if possible, but by ear, most common all over the world, like singing and whistling, should always come first For me, better later than never
Comment from : @christopherbridgett2130

What a dillemma I am a little scared of getting an actual teacher, I am concerned he will limit my play by ear fun and advancement which has been very fast
Comment from : @Darynthe

Both skills are important!!
Comment from : @michaeldrummond5450

Read by music
Comment from : @annabelwebster1857

I prefer ear cuz for me music Sheets is quite a bit hard for beginner pianist
Comment from : @BLACK_GOLD6

I mostly play the piano by reading music but I will take your advice and master both arts, playing by ear and reading music
Comment from : @johannbatson9262

Playing by ear is more impressive I wish I could play by ear I can usually figure out the melody by ear, but the chords are hit or miss, mostly what I think works with the melody, not necessarily what's in the recording And, forget about the rhythm
Comment from : @dansanger5340

i agree about the cons about by playing by ear because i experienced it however in the long run you will figure it out what finger should you use some notes might be missing in my case, i tried to learn to read music but don't wanna take more years to master it, many says it would be imposible to read music when you're adult so i rely on my ears
Comment from : @SaintShalria2025

How do I improve my sight reading?
Comment from : @AnnikaWalter-t4k

I play guitar I taught myself to read a little because I wanted to study a few music books that require it But I don't have much interest in reading beyond that Maybe over the years that reading skill will become a sight reading skill
Comment from : @Kevinschart

This video is very helpful
Comment from : @nrsannie

ear definitely ear :-)
Comment from : @KC9KEP

I'm on week 3 of my piano learning journey as a self-taught adult, so I don't have preferences yet I used to take piano lessons for about a year when I was maybe 7 and it was so boring I refused to continue Right now, I'm trying to learn with sheet music and I'm really grateful for a year of boring lessons and a few years of basic music education at school because it feels like I'm starting from two instead of from zero I hope that one day, I will be able to play some of my favourite music on piano by ear but right now, I feel that sheet music is helping me to learn the easier and smoother way to use my fingers while playing Also, sheet music is a tool that makes me feel less lost which is important not to get overwhelmed by my anxiety and perfectionism I'm starting to learn some easy pieces with both hands right now and having sheet music in front of me really helps However, for many songs I like, there are no easily accessible easier versions of sheet music or I can hear notes that just feel off (on YT videos with link to sheet music) and synthesia is just terrible, slow, frustrating and confusing way to learn for me personally So for that reason, playing by ear is necessity But right now, I decided to wait with that at least until I can play something intermediate We will see how quickly I can get there But I'm definitely enjoying your videos and advice I'm getting in them!
Comment from : @soledatbernie

I love playing by ear as I play for myself
Comment from : @satyaphotographer

My son plays by ear He was playing tunes on an old piano that I got for my husband from Facebook, but now he is in piano lessons to learn to read sheet music
Comment from : @Shiboys

read but my new teacher just started ear teaching I played by fake book
Comment from : @marciaalbaum2597

I've been noodling on the piano by ear since I was a kid without any formal training Learned to play a few simple melodiesbrbrAt 40 years of age, decided to start learning fundamentals and now I prefer sight reading as this can yield much better results and you can learn any complexity/nuancesbrbrStill, both are important You really enjoy music by listening to it, by feeling it I hope some day to be able to transcribe music by listening to it and create my own adaptations of it
Comment from : @makarenkoa

I played classical piano, age 5-18 I also played the trumpet At around age 18 I started playing by ear I would love to relearn site reading, but I've forgotten how to do that And since I was a trumpet player, the treble clef is "readable" but the bass clef still confuses me A "real" pianist is accomplished at both, IMHO
Comment from : @alansaville9003

Playing by ear n learning about sheet music
Comment from : @ShermanWilson-nj4wt

Those who lean more towards playing by sheet music typically come off sounding mechanical, stiff, lacking feeling and emotion and boring
Comment from : @rich135b7

A little each day of music theory, sight reading, and playing by ear -- don't overwhelm yourself! It's amazing how much a little each day adds up over the course of even just one month
Comment from : @MA-js5by

Hallo sir Am amrit What kind od exersise i need to start as am a begginer player
Comment from : @oneworldnation2802

I’m just learning the piano, I can only read sheet music, slowly but once I get this song down, basically a memorizing the song I can play the song with the book shut only way I can make it sound good is if I memorize it basically
Comment from : @billblack3775

Extremely helpful in addressing the 2 approaches
Comment from : @markfernandes4165

Obviously ear training is optimal Reading sheet music is not creating it's copying
Comment from : @integratedboxingsystem8827

I wish I could play by ear, but I predominantly play by sheet music After I play by sheet music, it helps me to play better later by hearing it by ear
Comment from : @NoMoreToxicRule

Thank you very much for your videos l find them very inspiring!brSpeaking of reading music, let me start by saying that I am an absolute beginner, my problem is that I have poor eyesight so I necessarily have to learn by heart and this makes studying very difficult for me Do you know if any apps exist and could be useful to me? Thank you very much
Comment from : @mariofirpo200

Jazer's tips are excellent
Comment from : @patriciaguillaume7353

When i learnt music at school i played what i saw on the sheet and passed exams with honours I always had a good ear and play by ear only for afternoon tea at a hotel Learning music was useful particularly when playing with other musicians who sometimes ask"what key are you in? I prefer playing by esr
Comment from : @patriciaguillaume7353

I learned how to read sheet music years ago when I didn't play any instrument and havent used it since I'm learning how to play the flute and doing it all by ear, to me it is just a lot more comfortable and fun I've been considering getting into learning the theory (seems like a pain in the ass) since I could benefit from it when playing with other people Havent watched the video yet, lets see if you convince me!!
Comment from : @paulatorralvo5400

I dont know what to do
Comment from : @cool358

I want to read it and play it! I already play by ear…a little bit
Comment from : @RussWhatley

I read sheet musique
Comment from : @noeprim2184

Hi Jazer Another delightful surprise is God’s gift, which has been instrumental in nurturing my child Music played a vital role during her healing journey from pneumonia, supporting her day by day As she expressed her fondness for it persistently, we decided to get her a toy piano We found that she was able to listen to tunes on the radio/TV and work out to play them on the piano To our astonishment, within just a month, she has already mastered playing nearly ten pieces Seeing her have fun while listening to her favorite songs and recalling cherished memories, or even learning from online piano tutorials, brings immense joybrbrI was both amazed and confused when I caught my 6-year-old child, Aigis, playing the sofa syllables on her toy piano and writing her analysis of the song "Happy Cat" in sofa syllables on a piece of paper She had stuck Scotch tape on each white key and written the corresponding sofa syllables in marker, which she plans to rewrite tomorrow since it got washed out while she was playingbrbrFor basic, she can play her own by ear, songs like Happy Cat, London Bridge, Jack and Jill, Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, Happy Birthday, Mary Had a Little Lamb, and Digital Amazing Circus opening Now she wants to make me happy so she's learning little by little by herself Pachelbel's Canon in D yung 1st stanzabr brI'm not sure how to manage Aigis at this point Is this behavior weird? Sometimes, she goes above and beyond my comprehension, and I'm not sure how to handle it Any advice would be appreciated
Comment from : @jenniferbfrianeza5401

Ear
Comment from : @frocen1

Very goodbr
Comment from : @huebnguyen

6:31 does anyone know what song he's playing? Great video, thanks for the help!
Comment from : @samn6760

I’m learning mostly by ear; but I want to learn to read music while playing as well
Comment from : @louiseparis4754

Both of them are best for learning the Piano 🎹 🎉🎉
Comment from : @emmanuelaboagye4624

I do both but to relax I prefer playing by ear - pick out the melody with my right hand and accompany this with chords with my left It's not that different to what Beethoven did with Fur Elise! This was a very good tutorial Jazer, thankyou
Comment from : @angeladavis891

Grandson 6 playing since 3 Has perfect pitch so he hears the song in his head and knows he needs to play a Bb He doesn’t read the music much
Comment from : @kathiefleming2830

I am clasically trained so most of my life I played music from sheet, while also being able to use my pitch skills and play melodies that I heard on radio right away But as time went on, I thought I was losing the fun in my piano playing, basically I lost my motivation to play And so now, basically thanks to a friend who plays mostly by ear, I feel very inspired to recreate melodies by ear more!
Comment from : @lenkaklapalova

I started playing music @ 9 years old ( started on laptop keys ) now im 33 and i really feel like i need to improve my technical skills of sheet music
Comment from : @LauriBeats

The most useful skill would be to be able to play from the score after having memorized the piece But I doubt it is even feasible to play from the score when the music is very virtuosic and requires one to look at the keyboard (eg, pieces that have many big jumps)
Comment from : @NN-rn1oz

for people who play by ear, they could now communicate and express their music much easily with programs such as synthesia
Comment from : @everythingalsoYUI

I am terrible at reading music But I am great at playing by ear I can play almost any song by ear at the first attempt However, I am frustrated I can't read music
Comment from : @dsimoes5

I prefer playing by ear because I don’t know how to read sheet music 😂
Comment from : @mzaure

How much does sheet music represent all the nuances of a piece? It's a visual guide but a performer have to play the music in the proper context When you see "Allegro" on top with no BPM #, you would consider a number of factors how fast you think the composer would like the piece to be performed It's a subjective opinionbrRobert Estrin did an interesting video: youtube/2QHueTW2UOM
Comment from : @thepianoplayer416

I think it's very hard to play classic music by ear I'm currently learning Moonlight Sonata 3rd movement, and it is impossible to learn it without notes
Comment from : @lovepiano4616

My childhood piano lessons had no aural training as far as I can remember And my first few teachers in my adulthood had little to offer in that area as well I definitely felt those last two talking points I often lacked expression and emotion in my playing And improvising was difficult because I had never really had to think for myself It’s been a long, occasionally painful 😂 road developing these skills, but I’m improving at least 😅
Comment from : @ruthterry3908

I like chord charts I am trying to get faster at reading music
Comment from : @BlurredTrees

I play by sheet music but would love to play by ear
Comment from : @tzz615

"that they play with less of an emotional engagement to the music" That is very important point! There are more mental somatotypes of students I belong exactly to this category I put effort into investigation why I have this problem and found that it is probably because the two parts of the brain that are used for reading (notation) and for musical experiencing are not independent enough, thus when reading sheet music, my musicality can't be developed well enoug Solution for me was to find proper method how to learn pieces from memory And it is another topic
Comment from : @MarioVapenik

I'm a hybrid I now play mostly by ear which allows me to be spontaneous - and it's easy (I confess, my ear-playing comes naturally and, it seems, genetically My Dad, his two sisters and a brother all played by ear) brPlaying by notes: I also slogged through piano lessons from age 11 - 14 I deeply regret having stopped Still, the foundation that learning "notes" gave me has greatly enriched my ear-playing I was diagnosed late in life with ADHD While the diagnosis was life-changing for the better, I mourn for the years of instruction I never sat for I often wonder if the synaptical business that created ADHD is in any way connected to my innate (and fairly modest) musical talent
Comment from : @WillBravoNotEvil

it rlly helps me alot :) thank u very much
Comment from : @whoispumpkinpie

I'm self-taught Therefore sheets
Comment from : @johana1513

I prefer sheet music
Comment from : @TemiloluwaOllyteeTV

I’m more comfortable reading music I would like to Lear to play by ear
Comment from : @anniemccary5814

Read sheet music as no confidence to be able to play by ear
Comment from : @shirleylittle3485

Agreed no comments perhaps the 3rd skills are by using ear observe U tube and try to catch the notes in slow motion especially for people who can't really read musicI always do it and it work
Comment from : @jawshua100

Lots of fabulous points here! I learned firstly by note and really appreciate visuals, however I am more and more leaning towards a merging of approaches I keep thinking that music is 'a listening art' and I so want to nurture musical making in ways that connect people That being said, I do love notation for many examples of advanced repertoire and am so thankful to be able to read notation with relative ease
Comment from : @MotifMusicStudios

Hello, it's my first time watching your video and I have a question:brRecently I saw you play songs with sheet music with notes on and you play it really good buy I never tried playing music with using notes because I usually play music using chords with no notes So my question is which is better, play music with only chords with no notes or play music with notes?brI hope you will answer my question 😁
Comment from : @FurZanProject

I'm more an ear / memory learner, but since you posted your previous video on the topic I learned to read music, and i surprised myself recently by "earing" what i was reading before actually playing it (on a pretty simple piece tought) Regarding the fingering, there not that much indactions on the material i'm used to play, and i probably should write it more often on my sheets (but i tend to rely on memory since it's easy to remenber a fingering you struggled to find by yourself)
Comment from : @lapindespices2806

You don’t need to be able to write music when you can use things like sibelius! When communicating rock and jazz musicians talk in terms of chord progressions They’ll say it’s a 1564 in A or they’ll say you can use B mixolydian mode over that… But yes with complex classical pieces you have to sight read them
Comment from : @tronlady1