?? Work at Pickup Points � Flexible schedule

The Best Way to Learn a Language, According to Science

TheLingOtter 46 views

Download Video

Comments

One of the most important things to do when trying to teach somebody a subject on a you tube channel, whatever it is, is to not have your microphone on too loud so that your voice is boomy and slightly muffled
Comment from : @warrensimpson3276

AI Peter sent me here
Comment from : @soiko1784

Personally, I'm trying to learn Na'vi, but progress is slow
Comment from : @aetheralmeowstic2392

I am a huge fan of input based approach Read graded readers, study new words, learn grammar from the books, listen to the audio Best way to learn It is impossible to fail Attendance is all you needbrbrTextbook study is dull and unproductive It is a necessary evil though You need some foundation to get you started But I suggest dropping textbooks as soon as you can read graded readersbrbrOutput/interaction based approach sounds nice but hard in practice If you have a Chinese GF who is willing to teach you Mandarin, good for you, you lucky duckbrbrBut most native speakers will not wanna talk to you until you get good And hiring a tutor is not cheap Language learning takes a lot of practice Paying for 3000 hours of interaction is unrealistic brMoving to live and work with a Mongolian family is too much sacrifice
Comment from : @lunedefroid8817

2:33 Amelie, French film when the man discovers the little box that has all his childhood treasuresbrbrGreat film
Comment from : @joeyjojojunior1794

Couldn’t you just talk to an ai that speaks another language for conversation
Comment from : @gatorboygaming6254

Lingo otter do you think I’ll become fluent in Russian 🥹
Comment from : @gatorboygaming6254

Lingo otter saved my lesbian hamsters, parrots, dogs, horse, aunts, best friend
Comment from : @gatorboygaming6254

I don't know any books or tv shows bwell/b I know shows but I do not know them enough to be able to quote or know what people are saying
Comment from : @Jesse-t1w3q

0:28 cuptoast (aka crumb) made that meme, by the way I can't believe i just got jumpscared by my favorite animator in this linguistics video
Comment from : @lilyofluck371

Input rules
Comment from : @benjamingraffi4265

I learn Italian and Irish in school and also on Duolingo at the same time, and that flows really well with my interest in linguistics, so I don't find learning my languages hard
Comment from : @kingbroxxo

I fully trust linguists who wear their food as hats
Comment from : @ZenoDovahkiin

I'm Swedish so I could actually probably become fluent in Norwegian in about a month
Comment from : @sirjilo8635

VRchat is the goat for language learning
Comment from : @malikknudsenramadan6572

does it work for third language learning?
Comment from : @jamesbackup2346

Your voice is so comforting
Comment from : @randomjazzpicture5108

In short, every fcking method counts
Comment from : @mingthan7028

OkcoolbrbrNow I am gonna read the bible in German
Comment from : @mingthan7028

can you make a video to help me know the right way to use skibbity or however its spelled
Comment from : @pleasedontwatchthese9593

I agree with your conclusion! I think a base from class and textbook is necessary, and after that you can ditch those and focus on intaking as much language as you can and coming up with your own stuff It’s actually crazy how natural language acquisition is You get so much better without noticing!
Comment from : @beenice1555

I just want to know why the otter has a fish on its head
Comment from : @beenice1555

I learned my 4th language through input ALONE i didnt even know that i knew the language until way after learning it So i know which method works for me now I wanna learn a lot of languages
Comment from : @Alpheus_09C

I'm learning English (A1) brsomeone wants to do a language exchangebrI speak Spanish
Comment from : @DanielGonzalez-61t0fAll

Out of curiosity, what languages do you have experience with? In other words, which ones have you studied?
Comment from : @user-ci9su6sy7r

ウェブの「今日」(いまび)知ってる？
Comment from : @alexclovis4590

尻が重い言語学者としてありがとう！
Comment from : @alexclovis4590

Are yoy a furry?
Comment from : @Tycini1

Can you talk about TPRS
Comment from : @MAFH_313

5:30 as an argentinian, i know that the red and blue rectangles mean the same thing, just that they use diferent dialects argentines, uruguayans, paraguayans, and central americans ALL use the words in the blue rectangle which mean the same as the red words, but stress the second vocals as showed with the stress mark (`)
Comment from : @Gregonimations

This probably is wrong but to me the difference between acquiring and learning is short term versus long term memory When it’s acquired it’s in my long term memory and I know it for good Of course this happens when I’m not paying attention because you can’t control your long term memory the way you can your short term memory
Comment from : @paulwalther5237

I was skeptical of this video until the GOAT appeared 0:34
Comment from : @RajvirSingh-m1n

I think the input theory example works for languages that has similar sentence structures as your native one but how would it work with one that doesnt? subject verb object, subject object verb
Comment from : @bomberfox5232

Output: Start YAPPING
Comment from : @Dad_K

can you talk about wittgenstein
Comment from : @_bofu

this video is so cute, but at the same time really useful!!!!!!! i love ur videos! I really thought that dobling was a word, bc English is my second language
Comment from : @eellauu

Watched for otter, came back able to learn french much better brJ'peux parle français meilleur maintenant
Comment from : @Worldtradencentre

So do a bit of everything?
Comment from : @skylarkkraken

I started "acquiring" greek a year ago I never learned a grammatical rule or conjugation table I now had the chance to go to Greece 2 months back and it was magical Never before have I spoken with another person but suddenly I was able to understand 60 of what I've heard I've had a 10 min conversation about the son of this woman who is a musician, studied in Australia and now tours Greece as a successful Lyra player It definitely was not a "beginner conversation" brbrI now am certain that within the next year I will reach a point at which I can call myself a greek - speaker brbrI have basically only read using lingq At the moment I am reading Harry potter in greek and am enjoying it because of the story A year back I knew basically nothing
Comment from : @goldmund2902

Im an arab who is learning spanish on the side any tips?(yes i speak english fluently)
Comment from : @muhannar

Inb4 dobble catches on lol
Comment from : @JapesZX

Why is it always a "second language", doesn't this apply to any new one, be it a second, third or whatever other number?
Comment from : @thefirstuwu8874

I learned 3 languages by finding friends who speak it and studying words on google translate and watching videos in targeted languages with that targeted languages subtitles ,and writing
Comment from : @music_observe

Me, a Latin student, looking for native speakers
Comment from : @just_a-nice-guy438

This doesn’t relate to this video and you don’t have to answer, but are you Chinese? Just wondering because there’s a whole lot of WeChat stickers you used for this video
Comment from : @thebestgachatuberever3864

I think Krashen is right in every way, except for the idea that input alone is sufficient It may be sufficient for a child learning their native language, but for an adult L2 learner, the amount of input you would need to truly acquire your language is massive The downside of being an adult is your brain is no longer plastic and you no longer have parents to give you comprehensible input for 8 hours a day, every day, for years The upside is that your adult brain is capable of studying the grammar, shortcutting and accelerating some of the acquisition processbrbrThe output part is also indispensable for identifying the gaps in your abilities When I'm listening to a podcast, I'm not always thinking about whether they used the right form of a verb, I just hear that verb and understand the meaning from context It's only when I go to use that verb myself that I have to both remember it and know how to use the right form of it
Comment from : @modalmixture

Great video! The best way for me was speaking Spanish to my students and Tagalog with my family If I mess up, I don't really get embarrassed, and my students appreciate the fact that I'm learning their native language Also, I concentrate only on speaking and listening I feel it is faster for me, and it motivates me to continue I now read here and there, though
Comment from : @ntatenarin

Im such a simp for you otter language person,i love your vids
Comment from : @shitpostazzi

Speaking with natives is a surprisingly great way to boost your language fluency I remember speaking with Spanish natives for the first time & I didn’t get to speak much due to anxiety But after a while(in like a week or so), I can now engage in conversation & most importantly voice my confusion & learn from them themselvesbrbrIt’s critical cuz your brain will notice you don’t use your input irl, & thus wouldn’t care much to remember it if it can Memory recall is a separate skill from simply memorizingbrbrI recommend putting pressure on yourself(safely) What I did was put my ego on the line by talking to some Spanish girls It was embarrassingly hilarious & fun brbrNote: I was intermediate when I started talking to natives but I wish I started earlier!
Comment from : @leonaise7546

this otter makes me feel stupid 😭
Comment from : @sm4rts5m

11:45 But the cute French guy I like doesn’t text me, so how do I practice my French😂? There are only Mexicans in SoCal, no French people lol
Comment from : @thehapagirl92

Funnily enough, you probably shouldn't tell anyone around you are learning a language, as studies show that commitment to a goal generally bdecreases/b in people who have made it public!
Comment from : @frenchertoast

Finally someone using scientific data to prove the value of output, to the dismay of input-only Talibans like Krashen and Kauffman As much as input makes up for the bulk of my learning, active learning like output or just traditional studying is fundamental to better your skills
Comment from : @gabriellawrence6598

Is this guy latino
Comment from : @AtypicalAnglo

As a fellow scarf-wearing otter who adores languages and linguistics, I've been loving what you make! Thanks for all the interesting, well-presented content <3
Comment from : @Choojermelon

I love your channel!! Keep up the great work 💪🏼 brI've been learning Spanish for almost a year now (traveling through Latin America for most of it) and this video is kinda like critiquing my learning style hahaha, honestly I'd say I've been utilizing all 3 theories (having only heard of input theory before) just off my own intuition and curiosity and I've achieved an impressive level of Spanish according to native speakers (I haven't taken an official test but I feel like I'm probably around b2-c1 although my Mexican friend says she thinks I'm probably around c1-c2)
Comment from : @yuvalyul

For the criticisms:br1) This one is a pretty weak argument against the input theory Even if he used words other than acquisition and learning, that doesn't detract from his main point And why do you need evidence to form a "distinction between the words"? He's communicating two separate ways to interact with the language, so he's using two separate termsbr2) nobody has ever said grammar wasn't necessary for speaking the language This is a total straw man argument What input theorists say is you don't need to "study" grammar, which is totally different You can learn grammar in Spanish the same way you learned it in English: inputbr3) I'm aware of gaps in my knowledge while reading or listening, too Speaking isn't special in thisbrbrPlenty of people will do hundreds or thousands of hours of just input before saying a single word And they learn speaking VERY quickly once their hearing is fluentbrbrIn fact, if you learn speaking too soon, you'll learn bad habits that will take like ten times as long to unlearnbrbrSpeaking does not teach you anything about the language, only input does all speaking does is train your muscle memory and only takes you a few weeks if you learn it towards the end
Comment from : @jonahbranch5625

this is so helpful! thank you, lingotter!! 🤟🦦
Comment from : @Max_LOZfan

Author at the beginning: I can't stand this lying in advertising any more, I'm a linguist and I know exactly what doesn't work and what doesbrbrAuthor at the end: There are 100500 theories and hypotheses and it's still unknown what works You'll figure it out yourselfbrbrxD
Comment from : @YaShoom

It would take a huge volume of reading material to learn a language's grammar by context alone Just the different combinations of expressions for a particular subject such as asking the time would require reading 50 books or morebr• What time is it?br• Do you have the time?br• What time do we have to be therebr• What time do you have?br•What time does it start?br• Do you have the starting time?br• Is that the right time?br• Time to go or we'll be latebrI could think of another 50 examples In another language they might require different conjugations, auxiliaries or some other grammatical device to make a different sentence Not a fan of reading alone with translationbrLearn the Grammar and make it interesting When you build a house you need the materials (vocabulary) and the schematics or architectural plan(grammar) of the house With just the building materials you can have a go at building the house but it will take longer and probably collapse
Comment from : @gandolfthorstefn1780

I bought the Korean translation of a manga to learn and so far it's been really useful I can't read full books yet but the everyday expressions as well as all the pictures for context and - importantly - a story that makes me come back are really helpful :)
Comment from : @TheCyanScreen

I think the reason none of the theories seem to fit in all cases is probably because different people learn languages in different ways An approach that works for one person may not work for another If you want to know what way you can efficiently learn a language, I recommend trying to learn Toki Pona first It shouldn't take you more than a few months to be speaking the language close to fluently, and you've just found out the way you are able to learn a language
Comment from : @raymiemiller1455

I agree with your conclusion I think using all these techniques in combination is the way to go
Comment from : @pianoman47

How do we approach as a an intermediate heritage how has a good understanding but lacks the vocabulary
Comment from : @Contestedshooter

there's only one language 🇱🇷🌽🏜🍔🦅💪🥔🔫🎆🗽
Comment from : @WHV

In German class, we constantly translated from German to Norwegian and vice versa, aswell as getting writing tasks in to be answered in German Also I took the class with two friends so it was fun and we constantly talked, and I corrected them, it also helped that I am a grammar nerd Therefore I actually got grade 5 in that class
Comment from : @Loanshark753