?? Work at Pickup Points � Flexible schedule

4 Stellar Coins: 1893-S Morgan Dollar, 1923 Peace, 2x Saint-Gaudens $20 - PCGS Open Box Grade Reveal

TheCoinGeek 4 views

Download

Download Video

Comments

The peace dollar has a big hit on the reverse near the head
Comment from : @robertfrye5161

I love peace dollars, but I’m hopeless at grading
Comment from : @heidigib01

also, the 1 in 1893 is centered above the denticle
Comment from : @johnwachter6369

23 -s didn’t have the strike( they seldom do) to merit a higher grade
Comment from : @stevenwaldman7313

Grading on the 23S Peace seems harsh, but fair Surfaces: Average (63-64) Luster: Dull-Average Strike: Average Eye appeal: Neutral
Comment from : @bulacano3014

Nice to have the 93s in any grade and no details But I think it should of been F12 atleast Just my opinion though
Comment from : @ronpettrey8871

On a positive note No Details and all great coins!
Comment from : @don951

call them and see if it was a mistake
Comment from : @THEBULK1023

wow i was thinkin ms 66 ,, yeah they must hate those coins
Comment from : @THEBULK1023

They probably melted a lot of the 1893 S Morgans so that could be the reason why it's 100,000 minted
Comment from : @archaeologymikey0072

I just keep learning more and more
Comment from : @marshallprice8503

Out of the 30k graded a 66 I would be willing to bet 10k are regrades trying to get that 67
Comment from : @wheelman0799

Beautiful coins 🤩👍🏼
Comment from : @CoinsAlexTStop

Ouch I had it at f15 I have to say the wear seems to show more in the holder Or maybe I just missed that the first time
Comment from : @tylonnplatinumthe3rd659

I think the '93S is undergraded PCGS really hammers the lower midgrades, especially brMorgans This coin is a VG10 all day long, weak rims or not Lots and lots of detail still there Good range coins are supposed to have very little detail left in the devices
Comment from : @timber72

Tucson has other coin shops??
Comment from : @timber72

I have no gold in my collection I want gold
Comment from : @mistermister124

I do not see the appeal of the Peace Dollars they all look like weak strikes and the "V" for the "U" on the obverse and the reverse has three "U" I guess the Heads is Latin , the Tails not so much
Comment from : @JD-fx1mb

The best coin shop in Arizona!!
Comment from : @sidneyosborne947

Those double eagles are stunners!
Comment from : @MichaelC_22

I’m sure you are right about that Peace Dollar but to me it falls short simply on eye appeal Just my opinion I’m sure you’ll have viewers who will think differently Those two Double Eagles are beautiful
Comment from : @saltwatersaddletramp7229

The 1923 Peace Dollar is at least a MS - 64 on a good day at PCGS a MS - 65 I have 1923 Peace Dollar thats a PCGS MS - 64 ( 736064/16374635 ) and yours looks a little better than mine
Comment from : @MikeSmith-yo9ch

Big tech and government intruding the hobby? Retaliation?
Comment from : @josevarjas8263

Peace dollar appears properly graded The strike looks awful!
Comment from : @ad2902

Could’ve been worse and came back CLEANED 😆
Comment from : @dvran

Like I have said, they are tough on Peace dollars
Comment from : @raymondnoah6394

What is the lowest gradded coin you have seen with a plus or a star?
Comment from : @pawpatrolnews

I saw the title and first thought "Stella"! 😲
Comment from : @NefariousEnough

The luster on the 1923 d saint Gaudens is STUNNING!!!
Comment from : @samsmobilepressurewashing8422

I dunno Ben you know we love you but the eagle on the 23S Peace is kinda hit fairly hard - including that Jack the Ripper slit across the neck My useless opinion vs your experience says 63 is fair for that one As far as the Augies go, wellthey're not 33's so graders actually do pay attention to the knees, and IMU(useless)O you got fair grades on those too I actually was going to say it was the 93-S that you got shafted on - ah but VGs usually need rims How are 93-S's usually struck? If they tend to be well struck you're probably stuck with the grade, but if they tend to be weak maybe the crew at NGC might go VG8 for you Oh well Hey at least you educated us again :-) Great videos and MUST SEE TEEVEE as always
Comment from : @louissicajr

OPEN BOX!!
Comment from : @Tiredsoutherndad

Good stuff! I like the 93S!
Comment from : @silversurfer1986

I thought the king of Morgans was the 1895 proof,880 mintage
Comment from : @667hodge

I misread the title as $4 Stellas at first
Comment from : @jbohanon2

Love pre 33 gold
Comment from : @ROGUESILVER

Hi, Ben 4 Steller had me expecting the $4 Stella Words matter The reverse of the 23 Peace Dollar must be what brought the grade down The obverse looks better On the Sts plus signs, they just didn't quite make the 66 grade, so would you rather they not put a plus sign and leave it at simply 65, or do you like the plus sign as a reason to justify a higher price? As a buyer, I would rather it be 65 and pay a 65 price I can tell if it has superior eye appeal I can tell if it is at the top of the grade range I don't need a price-increasing plus sign I guess there will always be a differing opinion between buyer and seller when a coin is on the borderline of the next higher grade I sure don't think PCGS should just go ahead and give a coin a higher grade If it is not worthy of the higher grade, it's not Your point about the higher value coin having a smaller population reinforces my opinion Especially with such a big price jump between grades brbTYU/b
Comment from : @donaldinnewmexico

Could be my eyes 👀 but, that 93-S looks better than a 6 The Peace Dollar is nice and those two Double Eagles 😍 are extra nice 👍
Comment from : @Ontario100

Only 100k made for that year wowww
Comment from : @josefigueroa3930

Two 93-S’s in one week? That’s a hoard in my book!
Comment from : @TiHerr74

Stella?
Comment from : @deanwest

A "plus" isn't like losing the Super Bowl Being neither a 65 or a 66, it's a football tie Or as they say "like kissing your sister"
Comment from : @jamesgoss1860

Ben, that 23-D DE looks like it's extremely well struck The face really pops out Nice coin
Comment from : @JohnD357

Great looking coins! Thanks a million for sharing 😎
Comment from : @tw-squared1196

Beautiful coins they look like they should had been a 66 all day long, thx for a great video enjoyed it very much 😀 👍
Comment from : @lewisoverfield5294

I know the fact with the two spots on the Liberty, but what is actually when you have an early strike without those stamp failures? you probably get a "not genuine" haha
Comment from : @ledsawify