Should we let students use ChatGPT? | Natasha Berg

Video quality	The size	Download

Information Should we let students use ChatGPT? | Natasha Berg | TEDxSioux Falls

Title	:	Should we let students use ChatGPT? \| Natasha Berg \| TEDxSioux Falls
Lasting	:	14.16
Date of publication	:
Views	:	182 rb

How funny it would be if her speech is written by chatgpt?? :>>
Comment from : @satyamtiwari7680

Watching ur vedios from london
Comment from : @DarFirdous-s2u

It is soooooo fun to watch this 2025
Comment from : @TheKindDoc

Gnutella Novella😊😊😅
Comment from : @nationalmediamuseum1974

we should teach students Adobe illustrator (ai) and Natural illustrator (ni) in order to design better factory machines, to reduce backbreaking manual labor and allow humans to sustain more efficiently
Comment from : @nationalmediamuseum1974

So, teachers are responsible for changing their curriculum when the government decides for them what and how they teach brbrThe government has curriculum guidelines and standards that all teachers have to follow brbrInstead it’s the government and the department of education that needs to change their role of from forcing teachers to comply with their demands rather than forcing teachers to change
Comment from : @fishercourt

If I had ChatGPT in 2001 in the 6th grade I'd be using it for every single assignment I didbrbrI had Final Fantasy games to play at home, man! 🤣
Comment from : @JustSomeCanadianGuy

The sad part is AI could create video like this even better explaining itself
Comment from : @youngok5493

It has enhanced my learning immensely I still think critically and read my classical literature or books I sometimes need an enhancement for getting my communication across efficiently and clearly I remember a lecturer telling me in 2017 that all colleges were moving away from exams I feel this is not the case anymore Exams will continue to be used until they develop something different that can assess students
Comment from : @Jinx301

permission to use a short portion of the video to include in our school documentary project for compliance thank you!
Comment from : @lleytonelacion449

As a teacher that just recently began using AI to assist with writing assignments, I appreciate this TED Talk! We as educators furthering our education are not able to utilize AI to assist with assignments
Comment from : @samanthabone1840

Yes!!!
Comment from : @AlexTSJLE

"It's the best part of my student life, which makes life incredibly easy"
Comment from : @nishatsheikh-lj8sg

Copilot is now my best friend
Comment from : @T0mF0rd

Did you just say "GPT 4, unlike chatgpt,"? Are you really that clueless on your topic?
Comment from : @aii8725

Educational system has to go beyond just submitting an essay or a dissertation Education would be compelled to start a result oriented mode Education must not be based on essay and dissertation
Comment from : @dhrubamaharjan8732

so bad
Comment from : @kiyogn2090

As a professor I have a particular level of expertise harnessed from reading, writing, teaching, and experience Years of multiple body of knowledge in a field I know the answer I should receive with certain questions that I ask GPT The problem is, a student doesn’t know if they got a comprehensive answer or not Only someone with a particular level of expertise would Moreover, Chat GPT and other AI programs are bias Because we are bias So, now you will generate more bias without sound vetting What I tell my grad students is AI is simply a starting point That is it
Comment from : @WWlogics

Its not a teachers job to train students on AI usewe teach critical thinking and reading and writing skillsget off your high horse Companies should pay for trainings that train their workers on AI use
Comment from : @Etherealmest

There may be a concern that it impacts critical thinking skills but for a student to effectively use AI tools they have to know exactly what to ask of it That takes critical thinking Sure they can easily ask a brief question but when they need something done with specific parameters they need to think critically so the AI tool they're using provides the best response
Comment from : @jamesh1113

I don’t understand why some people are saying it’s not the right choice to do because it might have some negative impact on you for me i use it to study and when i say “study” i actually use it to learn When there’s something I don’t understand and give myself chances to try and still get it wrong that’s when I use ChatGPT to explain the question and how it should be solved and so I get it faster than I do in school and I understand better I think it’s not about the tool itself but it’s about the way you use it If you’re using it to cheat and do nothing yourself to put effort to complete your work, that’s when you’d find negative effects within yourself but if you’re studying yourself reading the book and writing but only using it for hard and complex things that you couldn’t get them in mind here’s when you’ll get good grades
Comment from : @mawzza

AI is love!
Comment from : @JaBigKneeGap

such a good speaker
Comment from : @HyacinthNatividad

I’m already seeing results from this!
Comment from : @ThomasGray-z3k

No
Comment from : @anthonyniveaub1

Spoiler alert: she used ChatGPT to write those corny jokes 😂
Comment from : @makaronaldo

Maybe students should be learning how to write complex sentences with actual writing utensils on paper as well as developing a thorough knowledge and application of AI
Comment from : @kristinarumfelt

How did she teach them to write? THIS is the reason why students who end up in college don't know how to write (ie, to think, to communicate their thoughts)
Comment from : @saraghaffari5088

Should we let students spend time with something more intelligent than their parents and teachers?
Comment from : @francoisotis3560

Chatgpt is my professor, my personal friend and the god of education system Definitely using Chatgpt personalizes the given questions answer in most easiest understandable way possible A great salute to the engineers Lots of blessings to you people ❤🎉
Comment from : @shivakumarshindhe2695

I think it’s funny She says she had her students busy making posters and debates and games stuff that AI would not co-op from them but AI can do just all those things so what are the students left to do?
Comment from : @camillejt514

(((Berg)))✡
Comment from : @AngloSaxon-ns9oc

With how broken and outdated the US Education System is, I saw let Students use AI for whatever subject(s) they’re working on
Comment from : @oriongear2499

this TED made me nauseous Sounded like a lobbying effort on behalf of big-tech
Comment from : @DigitalAshes

she just mad its smarter than her
Comment from : @FrankStaltari-p3k

as a diesel mechanic student i like chat gpt my ai its the most helpful tool
Comment from : @michaelvillanueva240

As a high school teacher, the use of AI in the classroom cannot be avoided or banned Instead, teachers must learn how to use AI to enhance student learning Teachers should be showing students how to appropriately use AI in their class, rather than saying its simply "cheating" or not allowed
Comment from : @fionaallison7019

Maybe some day, ChatGPT will finally be good at math We are not there yet
Comment from : @elliot2008

“A five paragraph rigorously structured essay” is “approaching a concept [and] break[ing] it down into bit-sized pieces” — No, not the only way one can break things into bit-sized pieces, but the essay has been the approach that fits most any problem one encounters — a conceptual problem, at least brbrSo Ms Berg’s argument fails here, and does so obviously The opposition she erects isn’t an opposition at all, and (given her often return to “the real world”), the real world of the essay is one conversing with oneself Yes, students are writing to themselves, not their teachers, and not for distant bosses brbrThe final irony here is ms Berg’s entire 15 minutes: it’s an essay, and essay voiced and with a few illustrations I’ve not checked closely to see how many paragraphs she speaks, but do notice that once or twice she seems to be reading Are there five paragraphs here? Perhaps
Comment from : @paulfrancis4227

Good
Comment from : @rohanamohammad106

Also it is not 100 accurate and it helps to have a broad knowledge on your topic that you are writing about and in a sense "fact check" ChatGPT and it will correct itself and add your research findings to whatever your topic is that you are working on
Comment from : @mcs081485

Why does no one ask what music is for? If someone asks what math is for, it simply means they don't like it
Comment from : @antoniomacchi4230

The simple truth is that math, grammar, Latin, etc have no practical use whatsoever! They're just like listening to music or climbing a rock – purely for enjoyment
Comment from : @antoniomacchi4230

teachers are over! AI rules!
Comment from : @antoniomacchi4230

I'm a student I have been using ChatGPT since its launch and I have to say it's a game changer it's completely a new way of accessing information
Comment from : @NerdMind181

Great!
Comment from : @justinh5244

Thanks I finished my school before Internet 😂
Comment from : @Me-cat720

should we let students use me?
Comment from : @julibot_robot

So, while the education system figures out how to use this new AI technologies in a non-harmful for education way that really works, we will have to deal with various generations of students finishing their degrees (whatever they are) and having very limited knowledge of their field of study How can they be trusted to be incorporated into the workforce while this new approach in education takes place? I guess the education system needs to be a lot more rigorous in evaluating the actual knowledge of students via really hard exams, in a controlled environment and without access to any technology (except simple calculators) Students not passing those exams, must be "filtered out"
Comment from : @victorlarios420

Great episode
Comment from : @NicholasNerios

You're not talking about learning foreign languages !!
Comment from : @isabellelefloch1099

1:56 This is wrong It does not learn over time For it to learn, a new model has to be trained, possibly on a larger corpus of data A model like GPT-4 (the P in the name says it – PREtrained) just exists, might get finetuned here and there, but does not learn anything immediately from a conversation
Comment from : @mikhuber

i mean i definiety understand using AI as a tool for getting answer but lets be for real students are not using it for the right reasons I have watched people geting A and 100 by doing no work
Comment from : @tmoneyot

It’s like you don’t even recognize what the A in “AI” stands for How can you possibly receive an education when teachers and students are both just pretending they know more than they actually do? That’s not intelligence - that’s a con job
Comment from : @stchaltin

In era of chatgpt bye writting test and welcome oral test Sorry students
Comment from : @JulienBasto-sc6dn

She thinks getting a machine to transform Romeo and Juliette into a telenovella is a fabulous idea
Comment from : @intoconjunctions

Thank You ❤
Comment from : @chetanrawatji

❤
Comment from : @LoyalCreationTFE-qw3nt

Brilliant
Comment from : @soniacgc9184

Student use chatgpt AI halp
Comment from : @byPat-w2l

Africa will understand this after 100 years 🥸🥸
Comment from : @shekudaboh8982

Brilliant article Great listen and very relevant as a clinical psychology master's student
Comment from : @fieldswell

I use ChatGPT to write essay outlines I’m autistic and struggle to put my thoughts in order, especially with essays I give my thesis, say what kind of essay, say how many sources i’m using, and it helps me put what I want to say in order
Comment from : @kris8606

Amazing😊
Comment from : @No1Rocking_Beauchamps

Amen! It is time we embrace the technology and learn how to use it within the learning environments
Comment from : @MVPTS-fj7ru

I agree as a student, there are also some of my classmates that uses chatgpt for cheating but accept this for hard and complex question it helps me very much (especially writing essays)
Comment from : @Mrt1e

Awesome! Hopefully so much needed reform of education system comes soon
Comment from : @TheAzachiel

I am amazed ❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😊😊
Comment from : @Rachnaknowledgehub

Essay writing should be converted into public speaking Most of the student lack this skills , which is somehow necessary in today's world to express our views
Comment from : @zainulabdeen7154

If teachers and professors actually challenged and engaged students instead of making them regurgitate answers based upon appeals to authority we wouldn't be largely having this problem now wed be more well prepared
Comment from : @jdmchoes92

No one asked you for permision
Comment from : @samuellyngdoh9982

The teacher's are selfish If you get support from AI, and add your individuality to it, they still get upset
Comment from : @TENetwork4

I'm autistic and I used ChatGPT for my most recent term papers, not to write the whole thing for me or anything like that but, for example, to summarize long texts for me so I could see if they included the information I needed to cite in my paper Usually, reading these texts takes me ages because my neurodivergence simply does not equip me qith a long enough attention span, but having AI transform every paragraph into two or three sentences so I can see if I even need to read the whole thing helps a lot It also helps by simply transforming academic language into more easily understandable sentences which has saved me from quite a number of extreme headaches
Comment from : @ninreck5121

If we were kept from the future, we'd all still be walking and throwing spears to survive I'm seventy-two, never learned about computerization and mobile phones at school, and feel terribly backward now We can't afford to keep the future from the present
Comment from : @pepper419

The thing we still have to do is think and understand It can be easy to get mother to write a letter for you, but do you understand what she's writing?😏
Comment from : @pepper419

Should we let student know that an information revolution took place and you don't need to pay- let alone a fortune- for all knowledge now?
Comment from : @Real_Michael_Jordan

JOKES ON YOU TEACHERS, THEY'LL HAVE AI ROBOTS TEACHING CHILDREN VIA VR HEADSETS
Comment from : @4N7H6NY

"If students feel as though what they are learning in the classroom will benefit them in the long run, they will be invested in learning They won't be looking for shortcuts to simply get the work done" ❤
Comment from : @guru0503p

It’s funny that they don’t have to think for themselves anymore Ai is dangerous…
Comment from : @brickdabrick

Ask the student to complete a paper using AI That becomes their baseline How much better can they do with real intelligence? AI is not a crutch It is a challengebrLet the student ask the AI to evaluate the work It can guide teachers in this
Comment from : @digitaldrz

My college professor actually allows us to use ChatGPT for all assignments in his class if we want While its not always spot on its pretty useful, and quite honestly outside of being a student and actually learning stuff on my own there really isnt a reason to avoid it if you need help Very interesting stuff
Comment from : @theintrospective255

plz use subtitle Watching this video not only for motivate but also I try to improve my English
Comment from : @amarpathshala-7058

Consider it a resource
Comment from : @LongdistanceRider22

Let’s support this… I remember going to the university library I’m pulling up old test to study
Comment from : @LongdistanceRider22

Bravo! Thank you so much for your presentation! :)
Comment from : @tucsongreg1684

I dont think people understand what they are really saying when they "sell" this so-called advancement LAZY BRAINS, zero neurological development, reliance on technology, distorted thought processes, less common sense and last but not least- the ease of gas-lightability I have two masters degrees and one PhD I also speak 3 languages I didnt need any AI or software to get my degrees I was raised in the 70s I taught my kids when their teachers could not Spell check is a joke and I never needed grammarly MY BRAIN, MY ABILITY! not some technology! This AI is going to hurt our future brains Look how most idiots went along with the govt Covid mandate and got "played" AI equals gullibility Like they said in the 70s DO YOUR OWN WORK!! knowlege is power, not AI
Comment from : @c-hawkins1150

Essays always felt like a major time sink to me I mean, the hours we put into figuring out how to express our thoughts on paper is just mind-boggling Nobody speaks the way they write! Writing is fundamentally about communication, and if AI can help us enhance our written communication, it's worth a shot, don't you think? Perhaps it's time we shift our focus towards honing our speaking skills instead of dedicating so much time to writingbrbr- Written by ChatGPT
Comment from : @Azel247

Really enjoyed this knowledgeable session
Comment from : @priyajitkarmakar3296

I am all for technology at schools, but I don’t like that the past decade, educators and school admins jump on the ‘progression bandwagon’ without evidence that students actually learn better theough technology In the States, they got rid of hard copy books, replaced paper and pencil with tablets, gamifying learning without research and proof that this actually works better with kids and doesn’t cause lack of focus, problems with memory, or is suitable for all learning styles I don’t mean that we need to go back to Victorian times of schooling or that we have to get rid of technology What I am saying is that technology is just a tool, not the panacea for all problems, and we shouldn’t throw the baby (traditional style of teaching) out with the bath water because we found a more flashy toy Learning how to write a paper has much value in our life because it makes you a critical thinker, and makes you aware of the power of the words We cannot leave this to technology
Comment from : @sotiriakoui456