?? Work at Pickup Points � Flexible schedule

Being a Civil Engineer Vs. an Architect

Civil Mentors 652 views

Download Video

Comments

There is no conflict between the two 50 years as an architect I never got a problem with engineers
Comment from : @ramontanglao6466

Architect is the main conductor of all the engineers, civil, electrical, mechanical, sanitary, electronics, etc
Comment from : @ramontanglao6466

The best is an architect who is also an engineer like Santiago Calatarva (doctor of civil engineering) he designed most of the beautiful bridges in the world
Comment from : @ramontanglao6466

I dream of becoming an architectbrand wish that schools reopen soonbrso I can achieve my goals and dreamsbrIn Afghanistan, educational opportunities for girls are limited,brand this is a major obstacle to my futurebr😢❤
Comment from : @MASUODAYOLDASH

A good architect don't just come up with an idea, they consider every factor too brbrBut there is a famous one who ends up making death rays every time you let him design buildings 🤣
Comment from : @exnozgaming5657

But this is assuming that the only department in civil engineering is 'structural design'brWe also have soil mechanics, Water resources, geotechnics and much more
Comment from : @breemudi

thumbnail Haydar Aliyev Centre (Baku, Azerbaijan)🇦🇿
Comment from : @Coffy-

After going through the comment section, I feel like civil engineers are a cheap excuse
Comment from : @porteaisi686

Structural engineers are used by architectscivil guys make roads, bridges and solve the city's sewage and storm water run-off
Comment from : @atoms-to-atoms

Its Like Software Developer and ui/ux Designer?
Comment from : @celesox1448

So architects are basicly just Art ?
Comment from : @celesox1448

RCE ahh topic
Comment from : @ianplaysrablax

Im an architecture student but my former school didnt teach us anything they just expected us to design and thats it They didnt even guide us maybe some teachers but some just sit there , also the architect i know didnt even help me when i need knowledge im just in my freshmen and never really interested at construction but as i grew up i started to be interested in it so i chose this path so i needed a foundation for knowledge but no one is want to help a few and im thabkful for their sharing but some doesnt even bother I now mostly talk to engineers i learned from them especially my cousins , their all different types of engineers even my Dad I hope my new school will guide me well in this journey to become an Architect
Comment from : @Lalajeen12345

An engineer can't build without an architect So the architect is the main base the only thing is that an engineer knows all the calculation on building the house but they are both great love these jobs ❤😂
Comment from : @pharesarthur3308

What could be the solution for waterlogging on Delhi NCR roads? How can the rainwater collected on the roads be removed or utilized more effectively?
Comment from : @glaneeshk

Architects need civil engineers brCivil engineers don’t need architects brWe can all design structures, civil engineers can design with costs in mind
Comment from : @twinkieerella

Civil Engineers have a stable business which isn't affected by economic boom and bust cycles Hence employment is reliable, benefits are good, and chances for growth are excellent Architecture is an unstable business It is violently affected by economic cycles, there is high unemployment, benefits are poor, and chances for growth nill If you want to support a family, have a home, own a car, go on vacations, or have a retirementgo into Civil Engineering Avoid Architecture unless you are well connected into the upper echelons of US Society Architecture needs fundamental reform and educational reform The chances of changing this industry in the next several decades , given the narcissism, racism and egotism which poisons the field, are remote I've been in this field for 40 years and have told my childrenDO NOT GO INTO ARCHITECTURE!
Comment from : @007cloudsurfer

Reality of lifebr"Better action must start with a plan" and not just about drawing, it is the first step you need to follow to make everything in order, functionality and being essential
Comment from : @jay-argaem7269

This characterization of the architecture trade is absurd Whoever made this video did not survey the work real architects do I’ve never worked a day on aesthetics in my career Some interior designers, architects, landscape architects, and even some structural engineers do “design” - most architects focus on making a building constructable, code compliant and meeting the clients requirements
Comment from : @jmulliga7

nope not true at all; I recommend asking a local architect if you can shadow them for a day if you really want to understand the architecture/engineering interaction I often explain it as a conductor (architect) and the orchestra (specialized engineers) Imagine one without the other and you get a good idea of why both are valuable, and the difference in goal/responsibility of each Also, not sure what region is producing this video, but in Texas a structural engineer analyzes the structural integrity of a given structure, and the civil engineer covers drainage and parking lots
Comment from : @KevinMarek-z3u

Architects are UI/UX designers while civil engineers are coders
Comment from : @justchillin5084

Im civil engineer 😊
Comment from : @mrsingle3596

Architect are great
Comment from : @Mrngonimup-k4n

That is wonderful, I am also civil Engineer😶🌟
Comment from : @aamirshaz93

I never knew that there was so much tension between the two professions Can't we just design and build some shit instead of fighting over who does it better??
Comment from : @libraryofal_xandria

wwwyoutubecom/@tipstrickswithirfan9264/videos
Comment from : @NiadCh

Without civil engineers, architects can only dream 😢
Comment from : @dauthuc8807

Both is important to make dreams come true
Comment from : @markhagnaya8463

Dang this is why RCE hates architects, they get paid more for doing nothing
Comment from : @NapoleonBonaparte3

Can’t someone be both?
Comment from : @rustyshackelford3590

As a Architecture student, any type of Engineers are coolest and important 🧠 🤝🏻
Comment from : @ExArchUS-

Thank u sir❤❤❤
Comment from : @asimdas5716

I like you man you keep it real brArchitects are just simply Civil engineers who don't really like math , I'm about to choose a major and I'm stuck between the both , im average in math and good in physics so that's that , advise?
Comment from : @RSA-rchitecture

I am studying with civil, and i am good at art or you can say i can draw building structure Can i do both work at the same time in future ? Anyone who knows?
Comment from : @themisfityatogod8842

biStructural, Mechanical, and Electrical Engineers work more closely with Architects than Civil Engineers/i/bbr brCivil Engineers concentrate on 'Civil' Projects; roads, sewer, water, dams, airports, retaining walls etc As a Landscape Architect, I worked with Civil Engineers and Architects On some projects, Landscape Architects are prime designers and they direct Civil and Architects While in University I also studied Architecture, Urban Planning, and Civil Engineering We are responsible for Grading, Drainage, Site Access, among many other things that cross over to other professions On large jobs, it is definitely a Team ProjectbrbrbiGood designers have spent time in field working with their own hands and understand what a line on drawing means/i/b
Comment from : @SJR_Media_Group

👍👍😇😇
Comment from : @justinthomas8361

The builders are thr actual heroes
Comment from : @KingOfYourMouth

It is possible to be both an architect and a civil engineer
Comment from : @allimi_lumine4350

There are many civil engineering structures that have no or minimal input from architects- hydraulic channel and chambers, Treatment works drainage, cable support, etc towers,
Comment from : @billcorr4913

It's hard to be a civil engineer, living a petite narrow-minded life arrogantly I'd rather work with a structural engineer
Comment from : @WiFiTubeTV

An architect can do engineering work brBut engineering cannot do the work of architect but I am not a Be in both brBut but I do both 🤫
Comment from : @ajhonnayak5921

Even if engineers and architecture use their educational resource but those are labours from whom our world has developed brRespect to every labours from around the world 🌎
Comment from : @akitodaisuke6532

Is anyone on here a Civil Engineer? I have questions if possible Thanks(:
Comment from : @Nataliah3r3

Architecture vs civil engineering (similarity and differences)br youtube/LprSDRUTONU
Comment from : @civilarch9036

Final, without each other (also construction workers) a buildings wouldn't be built
Comment from : @ravenelbelleville3935

Hay quá
Comment from : @hungle5776

A commentary, thought or reaction video to “the Line” city project of Saudi Arabia would be cool brI think it’s very gimmicky and flashy but not really thought out
Comment from : @nihilus0

youtubecom/c/Jjcivilengineer
Comment from : @Jjcivilengineer

As a professional civil engineer with 35 years experience in public,private & industry only time working with architects was in consulting projects doing land development, which they designed buildings & conceptual site layout All other types of projects worked with other disciplined engineers Working in nuclear industry was very interesting, transportation most satisfying
Comment from : @jack333p

Because of architect civil ingineers can construct
Comment from : @fantasticworld1837

youtube/wJfbB1jbjFU
Comment from : @manimadasu7738

**Structural engineer
Comment from : @kirokyo

So,basically the architect creates the overall image and civil engineer brinfs that image to reality
Comment from : @rengokukyojuro8283

I'm proud to be civil engineering ☺️
Comment from : @spoidy3876

Architect are the actual thinkers
Comment from : @ohukwh606hgghk

Civil Engineering anytime!!!
Comment from : @Joshua_d_designer

Only one of them is an engineer 😂
Comment from : @thanosp8140

Thank you for this video
Comment from : @ginjie23

is it recommendable to study both of these careers?
Comment from : @kentozapater8972

I think people who try to compete here which one deserves more are forgetting that civil engineering derived from architecture back in the 1950 architects were the architectural engineers they did both So lets appreciate both
Comment from : @leafgreen_g

Can’t I be both?
Comment from : @LaeliaViviana

Civil Engineers are masters of Theory of Structures ❤️
Comment from : @rubentuting525

Both Architects and Engineers deserve credit Neither could work without the other, especially on large-scale projects Anyone who says otherwise fails to realize the complexity of construction in today’s society (Speaking from a North American standpoint) brbrAt multi-residential/commercial/institutional level - Neither could do the other’s work, and would burnout before the project went to Permit Project Teams can get very complicated and involve many stakeholders: Civil, Structure, MEP, Building Envelope, Architect, Interior Designer, Hardware, Security, Owner’s Rep, Construction Manager, to name a few…
Comment from : @lee-around

1978 ki building🏢 redevelopment mein kab jayegi br75 saalbr100 saalbr200 saalbr300 saalbrbr??????
Comment from : @anilkumarsharma8901

In the UK, everyone thinks the architect does everything
Comment from : @carlosd5031

So architecture have more opportunities than civil 😑😑
Comment from : @keshavthapa565

People just don't appreciate all the works that goes into designing a building Civil Engineers make what Architects image a reality, but the part of imagining is one hell of a task
Comment from : @far2kthoughts158

youtube/PbeysyQwQE4
Comment from : @mashhudazaki24

This amputee is in the book of mathematics in Jordan
Comment from : @محاكيشاحنات-ح8ط

I just want to let everybody knows that Civil Engineering is the Mother of all EngineeringCan you imagine the tasks and works they done in engineering world,Engineers are the best than Architects👌
Comment from : @donnamaegorez6703

I saw our famous bulding in baku center Haydar Aliyev center it is located city center and unique one
Comment from : @leyldeniz9037

youtube/cUJKPq7TZyA
Comment from : @suitablehouseplans

Residential/other Buildings are just a tiny piece in civil engineeringcivil engineering involves Water Resources, Environmental engineering, Railway engineering, tunnel engineering, highway engineering,Geotechnical engineering,etc
Comment from : @vinaybaviskar2644

This comment section turned out exactly what I thought it would be Always a war between Civil Engineers and Architects (most of them are probably not even in the said fields) In all practicality though, both fields work in tandem especially on big projects But on a much smaller scale such as housing, Architects are what most people would pick over Civil EngineersbrbrThough I find it kinda sad that when a structure is built, most of the time, the names of the Architects are the ones being credited/honored while the Civil Engineers takes the fall if the structure fails within 50(?) years after its construction Not to discredit the amazing Architects but that's just the truth (at least in the eyes of the CEs)
Comment from : @kuyaforce6103

Proud to be a civil engineer
Comment from : @asharuddeentharammal1131

I always wonder how can you design something without performing any calculation
Comment from : @hazwanpnu7321

Rephrase the sentence to "What's it like being an Architect or a Civil Engineer" always lead the Architect because his the Master Builder
Comment from : @jfc4514

Meme I saw a while back:brEngineer: "I've designed a luxory home made out of the strongest concrete that money can buy"brArchitect: b"I S A W E D T H I S B U I L D I N G I N H A L F"/b
Comment from : @cloaker7237

There'so need for comparison They both work together to give us the best structures that we have now As an architecture student myself, i really admire engineers for all the complicated problems they are solving However, architects are more than just designing We learn engineering science too and proper space planning and plumbing You may say that an engineer can design also, yes i agree but still, it is not comparable to the amazing designs of the architect
Comment from : @stateyourname9775

Architect: Function brEngineer: Structurally Sound
Comment from : @sauce8277

Architects are just annoying art majors
Comment from : @Alexr096

Architect: make things look coolbrEngineer: make cool looking things work
Comment from : @Funwithaball

Wonderful!
Comment from : @Chandra_Pars

Civil engineer is an architect and much much more
Comment from : @ΓΙΑΝΝΗΣΓΙΑΝΝΕΛΗΣ-κ9ι

And what about construction lads?
Comment from : @mohdjubair4385

Plan A is Civil engineerbrAnd Plan B is Architect
Comment from : @leklaus4018

el spam me trajo aqui
Comment from : @percyjramosmarin7397

they are both important
Comment from : @elel4440

So civil engineers have a much more responsibility while monitoring the construction site, working with the architect, and making sure the building is provided with things that it needs So basically like checking the architect blueprints/work and making sure everything is correct So I would just hire a civil engineer for good that I can work with on the daily
Comment from : @KaviusJones

can a structure engineer also design the detail asthetic of building?
Comment from : @lazna649

I can't help but notice on how hot these guys are
Comment from : @um485

When the building succesfull : people's says, who's the architect ?brWhen the building collapse :people's says who's the civil engineer ?
Comment from : @ikanputih