Best Bullion Coin? Canadian Silver Maple Leaf VS American Silver Eagle

Video quality	The size	Download

Information Best Bullion Coin? Canadian Silver Maple Leaf VS American Silver Eagle

Title	:	Best Bullion Coin? Canadian Silver Maple Leaf VS American Silver Eagle
Lasting	:	12.41
Date of publication	:
Views	:	78 rb

🍁 🏆 🥇
Comment from : @seftonwalker3978

The main reason I don't like the eagles is the fact that there are so many counterfeit eagles out there
Comment from : @julieferguson9986

type 2 eagle so ugly design, type 1 is pretty
Comment from : @MakkerDon

Maples more but never pass on eagles,at the right price
Comment from : @chrishoppe3041

Around the world? Everybody like Canada; America has lots of enimies
Comment from : @kenpeters9807

If you send me a tube of both ill get back and tell which coin i like better
Comment from : @ypebijker

US all the way 10 times larger economy military with no peer Which would I choose? Hmmmmmmm!
Comment from : @marionking-cd7dw

What gloves do you use?
Comment from : @richman3808

100 maple Canada has us on this one They will be the 51st state soon 😂
Comment from : @Adrian-wm3gs

Here in Canada the silver Eagle gets a big premium for what ever reason!
Comment from : @larryangelasmith2799

How will a 25 tariff affect Maples?
Comment from : @georgeloveday9674

Kookaburra obviously
Comment from : @maxwelldumstorff155

ASE's for me
Comment from : @johnpower8356

goverment: this silver coin is worth 1$branyone: can i buy it for 1$brgoverment: no that's gonna be 31$branyone: ok, i buy it, now i want to swap it out for cash, give me my 31$ backbrgoverment: no, it is worth 1$branyone: __brbrS T O N K SbrLMAOOOObri tought banks adjusted the silver oz value yearly or something like that based on the spot price or at least a bit below spot price but straight up 1$ WTFbror imagine a gold coin worth 2500$ being sold for 50$ biggest scam ever
Comment from : @hibosmo

9999, $5 face value, and because that is the one I bought starting out MAPLES!!!
Comment from : @Deeg4570

I would prefer not to look at a boring leaf, and a wicked monarch A monarch that believes that God has ordained him to rule over the people brAs an American, the Maple is nearly blasphemous
Comment from : @copperbones7336

Both Both are good
Comment from : @ExtraSqueaky

I agree that the CM is a better buy BUT as states recognize PM as currency, most recognize US minted coins
Comment from : @kenpeters9807

Beauty:maple with the queen
Comment from : @kenpeters9807

Stack both, those maples are beautiful, I have a bunch of 2023 and i love them, definitely higher quality on older ASEs, all the 2016 I have are beautiful, my 2024 just has a dull look compared to the maples and older Eagles
Comment from : @jb1996BLOP

Maples all the way 🇨🇦
Comment from : @DC-vw7yf

I love the maples
Comment from : @jordanmorrow1631

Maples 100 Way nicer!
Comment from : @tonyt5316

My first silver purchase will be Britannias
Comment from : @pteromalid

I am a Maple fan In my area they are also easier to sell because they aren't as common in shops
Comment from : @cknorris

Since there is no tax on the purchase of American Eagles does that factor into the price when buying and selling Eagles or Maple Leafs
Comment from : @The12348567

I had forgotten you do videos on your own and not just all videos at the coin shop I'm glad because the coin shop videos are helpful but seem to be kinda fake even though there is good info in the videos and some entertainment value I like your videos from your studio Glad you aren't just helping a very cool old coin dealer move his product I know all of your videos take time and effort but I like your stand alone videos better although you're getting Hella view hours out of the coin store vids You're a smart YouTuber with a really good coin shop to lean on Keep doing you I'll subscribe Happy new year
Comment from : @OutdoorGearAddiction

I totally agree with all of your points except that I like the look of the Maple better I agree that "King Charles" image is ugly and undesirable though,just don't turn the leaf over and look at his image Lol
Comment from : @rustyrooster4879

Im sticking with American minted coins :)
Comment from : @Ihatezidiotz

I like the maple because they are slightly smaller in diameter and I like the ping TBH the Krugerrand has the best ping…I still need to get a Britannia and Philharmonic before I decide which one is my favorite…but for me it will come down to ping and diameter It’s silly but that’s just me
Comment from : @drm-qg2fr

I have Maples, but I bought the ones that went slightly milky Also purchased the half oz Calgary Stampede coins that do not have any milking The milk spots are a bummer, the Canadian Mint should replace them, it's their mistake
Comment from : @MrAllan9

There are tax exempt benefits of selling American mint coinage
Comment from : @scottishgold6595

With only a few more years of Trudeau, Canada won't even exist, so the Maples will be worth even more
Comment from : @jaredroussel

Maple Leaf is a beautiful coin and hands down better looking than the Eagle Seems struck better as well This makes me want to buy some Maple Leafs!
Comment from : @HH-gn9qt

Could you spend a little time discussing the taxes end when you trade in for cash? Maybe talk it over with Harry the next time you’re in his shop?
Comment from : @NutmegRail

Im American but the maple is prettier
Comment from : @kkttss1928

Found this video and I am now subscribed It was outstanding in there it was perfect and analogy was exactly what I needed Well done
Comment from : @terryoliver1410

I stack strictly for value Hands-down only maple ! Pretty has nothing to do with retirement value Regarding anything that’s collectible in the way of coinage I’ll take a pass The loaf of bread cost analysis silver in the worst of times a rare coin ain’t gonna get you an extra slice
Comment from : @terryoliver1410

The cheaper one
Comment from : @jacekjam8643

5oz libertad
Comment from : @donsapunk

Hands down the obverse of the ASE but I dislike the reverse Depending on price and spread I will most likely buy the maples If the reverse of the ASE was more like the pre 1921 silver dollar or pre 64 half dollar I would buy the ASE
Comment from : @leeshafer5656

I prefer the Canadian Maple 🍁 Leaf 🍃
Comment from : @jopiaspieder1184

I like and have both but my Maple Leafs are before they started putting lines all over them and the leaf sides are ireally/i pretty I also like the slightly more chunky feel of the Maple Leafs
Comment from : @Chuckles

Just bought a roll of 20 silver coins for $34 a piece I guess I over paid but it’s my first time buying them
Comment from : @ChristIsLord7

I can’t say, which is better, it depends on trying to use both of them for barter how much of the population would accept each particular coin in trade for goods and services?
Comment from : @richardladow4734

Keniivyonenberpriz
Comment from : @PierreAntoine-n7i

Neither reallybrBuy your lowest priced generic round and keep stacking
Comment from : @islesanctum833

The silver eagle is a very Boring coin The maple is semi proof, and a better looking coin with great security features The silver eagle is SAD
Comment from : @weniwidiwici726

I did the spread math at my coin shop and the non DNA maples are actually better than generic rounds if you can believe it While the rounds are cheaper to buy the purchase price is lower enough that the maple comes ahead The DNA maples is another story however as they cost me quite a bit more to buy and don't reward you with a much higher buyback to match it I have to say I also HATE looking at prince Charles so this is another good reason to be buying the older maples Mind you I don't like looking at Queen Elizabeth either I do have to say that the maple itself both on the silver and gold coins looks really amazing and has a special "sparkle" to it that I really like
Comment from : @Matt-man69

anything that is minted from various countries, it shouldn't matter
Comment from : @RA-Redacted68

I buy either one that has the lowest premium, usually maples, but sometimes Eagles are on sale, especially lately
Comment from : @robertbush8327

Definitely the Silver Eagle
Comment from : @josephselch5769

Design wise my favorite are the maple leaf and the krugerrand
Comment from : @aceg7098

Our US dollar is less valuable than Canadian money
Comment from : @123playland

My LCS pays a lot less for Maples because of their history of milk spots, even though that problem has been corrected in recent years They don't want the hassle of differentiating by year
Comment from : @bkm83442

You buy Sovereigns when living outside the western world
Comment from : @tylernathan7985

Anti-counterfeiting???? If you can’t tell silver is silver in ounce sizes you have no business ducking around with it
Comment from : @tylernathan7985

I buy both coins I usually slab the Eagles and just stack the Maples in the tubes and forget about them
Comment from : @ericsautos

For stacking it is the Maple but being an American and loving America and I love the Eagle old style which is what I buy mostly because of strength and beauty The other thing to consider is the Eagle is a stronger made coin
Comment from : @ericsautos

So glad you did this video because I have been trying to understand it all My biggest concern though is because it’s Canadian will you have the same buying power here in America if times go bad Because I just know in regular Canadian coins people won’t accept those even vending machines won’t accept those For that reason, I just feel and I don’t know anything about this stuff, but I just feel that buying the American is better for me for peace of mind I could be wrong
Comment from : @grasscutter1963

If you have milk spots on your 2018 coins are they less valuable??
Comment from : @Goldie-ANNEFARGO

British Britannia beats all with lower premium and 4 security features
Comment from : @titiung

The best 1 oz silver coin is just a simple, cheap silver round (or rectangle) When you go to sell the two above you will get no more than you would for a simple silver round
Comment from : @ed345

Dragons, can you do a comparison with ASE, Maples, and Libertads?
Comment from : @edgararellano5671

Sorry, can’t buy anything with King Charles face on it
Comment from : @floridaman4073

Overall I like the maple leaf better🙂
Comment from : @coolvideos777

I hate to say it, but King Charles' doesn't look the best on the maple leaf😢brbrI feel bad saying that😢
Comment from : @coolvideos777

Love the Maples
Comment from : @michaelcampbell2147

Silver is silver so whichever is cheapest is the best This is a pointless video
Comment from : @stanleybaldwin401

What about the silver Britannia?
Comment from : @picklerick4944

I only buy American silver eagles, not interested in anything European or Canadian, just personal preference
Comment from : @eddiebaird8368

Maple is more pure
Comment from : @Dbodell8000

Best price is the winner
Comment from : @timf2279

The only problem i have with the Maples,is the royal family on its side The leaf is beautiful,but Charles III is 🤮
Comment from : @carbonduke01

How much do Eagle's cost? I live on the East Coast of Canada and I'm pretty sure the price of the Maple Leafs go for between $4000 to $5000 depending on year, condition, etc 2024 King Charles III Maple Leaf from the RCM is selling for $5400 to almost $6000
Comment from : @JasonWatsonWatty

The Maple Leafs, the last few years the small leaf mark on the coin can be scanned You get the whole history of that coin From blank planchet to struck coin
Comment from : @JasonWatsonWatty

I'm Canadian, however my favorite coin is the Mexican Libertad, truly a beautiful coin in silver but especially in gold and especially as a proof coin And the Mexican mint is the oldest in North AmericabrThat being said, I like the maples, but do not want to see "King" Charles on my money Canada needs to grow up and ditch that idea I was sort-of okay with Queen Elizabeth II, but Charles? Come on, he's a goofbrUS Eagles are nice too, nothing against the eaglesbrI'll take any pure silver bullion coin, the silver is what matters I also have a Philharmonic, a Britannia, a Krugerand, a Kookaburra, an Armenian Noah's Ark, a St Helena Silver one ounce coin (nice one!), a Nicaraguan Tortoise, and a Ukrainian Archangel Michael one ounce coin (a very nice coin! Slava Ukraine!) I also have some Silver Shield one ounce silver coins - "in Debt and Death They Trust" I love them all!brI do not own nor ever will own a Russian Ballerina (Nyet!), nor a Chinese Panda
Comment from : @supermash1

I'm in Canada, love the Maple, and love the savings brbrThat said, stack the coin of your realm If things get weird, you'll want the home made stuffbrbrSo that is an ASE if you are in the US
Comment from : @martinrev8487

I did what you and Yankee advice before buying anything and that was to ask my coin dealer what he would buy faster, no doubt and he said the Maples so although I'm going veeery slow, I want to do Maples (hoping not to find Charles on them and go from the late Queen to William (or whoever xd))
Comment from : @lopezjuan316jl

Re: The missing reed br US mint official: We're going to use a missing reed as a anti-counterfeit measurebr Silver Stacker: But that can be easily fakedbr US mint official: People shouldn't be counterfeiting coins
Comment from : @drmodestoesq

Thanks Silver Dragon I am glad you included the MINTSHIELD Trademarked technology Since 2018, The Royal Canadian Mint has included this coating to help with any potential 'milk spots' I agree wholeheartedly with your final analysisGo Maple Leafs!! LOL
Comment from : @rmarshall6747

nope the eagles i like are the gold ones with just the head of the eagle ^^ can't wait tommorow my 3 perth mint coins are arriving ^^ i'll unbox it tomorrow on my stacker channel that i just made, as soon as i receives it, and i'll show my two coins from last month (2x 1oz Krugerrands silver) and tomorrow 3 1oz coins from perth mint with one of my favorites : kookaburra (2024 this one,silver) but yeah next month i'll take the same 2024 kookaburra but in 1/10oz gold ^^ , the two others of perth mint for tomorrow are a surprise for the video lol ^^branyway i really have found a new passion with stacking,,, and there's money i use for "not usefull stuff like games etc, it's usefull but you just spend , here you transform in something tangible an that hold its value even getting bigger year after year,,,, money burn my hands, but now i love to stack and you don't want to sell your collection as i count on doing this all my life, so yeah if i want to get the money i have to make the choice to separe me of a few pieces but if it's really usefull like buying a car etc, but if not well it can't burn your hands as you need to go sell the stuff and you want to stack to more possible, actually this month i economise double of last month and next month i'l still gonna have more money, by not buying sh**tty stuffs ^^
Comment from :

Breakdown on spread should be based purely on percentage Using your example one would conclude that premiums on gold are way higher than on silver when the reverse is true
Comment from : @nathanielwilliams6609

I'd be curious to see a series like this comparing a few of the low premium niue coins against the maples the same categories
Comment from : @Tenacious21

I hate prince Charles so it's a no for me Like the leaf side though
Comment from : @AmericanProspector1776

Whichever one I can get as close to spot as possible Don't care about milk spots and neither will the refinery when the 💩 hits the fan They will care about weight and purity only
Comment from : @WeedenRoberts-wp9qw

I like the Maples They also have 15 and 2 ounce versions as well which make them even better
Comment from : @preparedsurvivalist2245

You had to flip to the King Charles side in order to win the beauty contestlol
Comment from : @JohnDoh-c7g

lol, Canada is fallen Half the categories awarded to the maple leaf are moot points Silver Eagles all day
Comment from : @vernfromthe6ix

Silver is cool
Comment from : @JessicaLeGrand-c6f

Totally agree Silver has a tendency to tarnish or turn milky Having the coin that had resolved that problem is a big plus Maples all the way!
Comment from : @seninamak289